Lawndart wrote:Wazzup!
It's an aging platform, that's all... Besides, before getting the Hornets the Navy expressed wanting a Fighter with Air-To-Ground capability to add to their forward projection of force, which is why the F/A-18 fit the role well (the first Fighter to have an F/A designation). The Tomcat was built for air superiority and long range intercept, the Hornet is a multi-role fighter (compromise, but more effective in cost savings as well).
Thats where Northrop Grumman needs to come up with an F-14E
Lawndart wrote:The Tomcat was built for air superiority and long range intercept, the Hornet is a multi-role fighter (compromise, but more effective in cost savings as well).
LD we know what ya mean, and how expensive the beast of the sky is...but the long range capability is "STILL" the most important part needed for the navy.
Tomcat=Combat Radius ( to and back ) 2,000 miles / 3,200 km. Add another 250 miles cause of the AIM-54C
Super Hornet=Combat Radius ( to and back ) 1,290.8 miles / 2,074 km (no external fuel, BUT with externals it only matches the tomcat having 1 external)
Overall:
Being 25 years younger then the Tomcat, the Super Hornet has an advantage in both stealth and modern day technology. Design to carry out both "air to air" and "air to ground" missions, the new generation of the F-18 Super Hornet offers more longer range, greater endurance, more payload-carrying ability, more powerful engines, increased carrier bring back capability, enhanced survivability and a renewed potential for future growth compared to its F-18 predecessor. The crew station also features a touch-sensitive, upfront control display, a larger, liquid crystal multipurpose color display and a new engine fuel display, making the Super Hornet one of the most sophisticated and ATF in the world
SO ??????
With more technological advanced weapon available to more unstable countries (such as the new generation of Migs and the new Russian Anti-ship missile), fleet defense has ever become more important. While the Super Hornet might be the next generation of the navy super fighter, there has been doubt whether if it can carry out air to air combat in long range distance. The Phoenix missile is designed especially for the F-14 Tomcat, it is able to destroy any given target within the range of 60 miles.
With the end of the cold war, governments in the western world are looking into more flexible and money saving equipment, such as the F-18 Hornet series which is known for little m (maintenance) and big R (reliability). The F-18 Super Hornet is definitely the more advanced technological fighter with superb air and ground capability at a cost of 35 million dollars (3 million dollar cheaper then the Tomcat), but the F-14 Tomcat is still the superior fighter because it is able to reach a longer distance and engage multiple targets and destroy them simultaneously (which is needed for the first line of defense in naval warfare), in a time of war and the protection of the fleet.
Only time will tell if it is a mistake to replace the F-14 Tomcat with F-18 Super Hornet as the carriers first line of defense.